Professional Tool Reviews for Pros
The Mac Tools Impact Driver does just about everything well and is a pleasant tool to use. It's very much a sort of DeWalt model for mechanics that really want the convenience and service of a tool truck. But you're going to pay for that convenience. At the list price, the Mac Tools MCF886 is higher than DeWalt's Tool Connect DCF888. If your Mac Tools rep can work a deal that works for you, pull the trigger. If you'd like to get more bang for your buck, grab either DeWalt's DCF887 or DCF888 to get the same fit, feel, and finish with a few more bells and whistles.
We tested 30 impact drivers in our recent Head to Head Shootout. The Mac Tools Impact Driver finished that competition in an overall 10th place. Although finishing most categories in the middle of the pack, this impact driver does have a few qualities and features that set it apart.
The Mac Tools Impact Driver does just about everything well and is a pleasant tool to use. It’s very much a sort of DeWalt model for mechanics that really want the convenience and service of a tool truck. But you’re going to pay for that convenience. At the list price, the Mac Tools MCF886 is higher than DeWalt’s Tool Connect DCF888.
If your Mac Tools rep can work a deal that works for you, pull the trigger. If you’d like to get more bang for your buck, grab either DeWalt’s DCF887 or DCF888 to get the same fit, feel, and finish with a few more bells and whistles.
* Results as of February 11, 2019. Check out our Best 18V Impact Driver main page for updates as new models hit the market.
The two main areas we tested each impact driver are speed and torque. Head over to our Best Impact Driver main page for our testing method details.
On paper, the Mac Tools Impact Driver has a no-load speed of 2,800 RPM with 3,200 IPM. It also generates a respectable 3,000 in-lbs of breakaway torque. What’s interesting in that Mac Tools doesn’t list their fastening torque like everyone else. It’s an automotive brand, so that’s a form we’re used to seeing in that sector, but c’mon guys.
Please realize that our torque tests do not and cannot replace how manufacturers test for their specifications. Head over to our main shootout page see the details.
In our speed test, the Mac Tools Impact Driver maintains 448 RPM under load. We expect to see a Pro-level impact driver in this class hit at least 400 RPM. This tool can hit this mark with a comfortable margin and has no trouble driving a 1/4″ ledger screw and settles in at 9th place for this test.
You can expect to drive anything up through timber screws and smaller lags. I recommend getting your hands on an impact wrench if you’re going to drive anything larger than those.
For this test, we see numbers up to 2,700 in-lbs for some of the heavy hitters. We like to see these tools generating at least 1,500 in-lbs to give us the confidence to drive longer, thicker screws.
The Mac Tools model does enough to check that box. Pushing 1,556 in-lbs of fastening torque, the Mac Tools Impact Driver ranks 13th on our 18V charts.
Breaking 3,000 in-lbs, Mac Tools joins 5 other models in a tie for 6th place in nut-busting torque. As the only tool in the class to actually quote a breakaway torque spec, it’s nice to see our test confirm its claim with an equal value.
Mac Tools’ impact driver weighs in at 2 lbs by itself and only 2.8 lbs with its compact battery. This edges out Makita’s tiny XDT16 impact driver, putting it in the pole position for the weight category.
While the Mac Tools MCF886 is a lightweight, it’s not as small as you might think. It has a length of 5.5″ and stands 7.8″ high. This slides it into the 8th place spot for the size category.
Falling right into the middle of our 97 – 105 dB(A) range in a joint 6th-place tie, the Mac Tools Impact Driver generates 101 dB(A). It’s enough noise to cause some damage to your hearing over time. Better get some hearing protection.
The remarkably similar feel to DeWalt’s 20V models isn’t an accident. As the tool truck brand for Stanley Black & Decker, Mac Tools and DeWalt are cousins and they take advantage of the relationship with interchangeable batteries. That’s a win if you ever decide to pull a single DeWalt 20V Max tool into your shop or you want to grab batteries at your favorite home improvement store.
The Mac Tools Impact Driver has a really effective air intake at the base of the handle that does a great job at moving air through the housing and cooling down the motor. It’s more open than any of the other models we see, likely because its habitat is in the automotive industry where it’s not as likely to encounter wet conditions.
Since Mac Tools is a tool truck brand, most of what I’m about to say won’t come as too much of a surprise – this impact driver kit is a little pricey. It retails for $360 and includes the tool, a 4.0Ah battery, a 2.0Ah battery, a charger, and a case. The bare tool is $210.
DeWalt’s current leading impact driver (DCF887) runs $129 as a bare tool and $279 as a kit. Toss in Tool Connect on the DCF888, and it’s another $50. Either way, you’re still under Mac’s pricing.
Despite the high cost, it performs high enough to bring it up to a 11th-best value for the 18V class.
The Mac Tools Impact Driver does just about everything well and is a pleasant tool to use. It’s very much a sort of DeWalt model for mechanics that really want the convenience and service of a tool truck. But you’re going to pay for that convenience. At the list price, the Mac Tools MCF886 is higher than DeWalt’s Tool Connect DCF888.
If your Mac Tools rep can work a deal that works for you, pull the trigger. If you’d like to get more bang for your buck, grab either DeWalt’s DCF887 or DCF888 to get the same fit, feel, and finish with a few more bells and whistles.
When he doesn't have his hands on tools himself, Chris is often the man behind the camera lens making the rest of the team look good. In his free time, you might find Chris with his nose jammed in a book, or tearing out his remaining hair while watching Liverpool FC. He enjoys his faith, family, friends, and the Oxford comma.
Updated DeWalt 20V Max High-Torque Impact Packs More Power More power is always welcome for tough fastening jobs, especially in professional or commercial capacities where time is money. DeWalt plans to help with the 20V Max XR High Torque Impact Wrench (DCF900). An update to the previous model (DCF899), this model improves upon the high-torque […]
When it comes to drywall screwdrivers, Makita has a deep lineup of both corded and cordless options. From the field-tested FS4200 and FS6200 corded models to the newest XRF03 brushless option, you’re sure to find a Makita screw gun that suits the way you work. Makita XRF03 18V LXT Cordless Auto-Feed Screw Gun The most […]
HART Impact Sockets Up Your Impact Wrench Game Without Breaking Your Wallet So you bought an impact wrench and you’re ready to get to work. To save some money, you’re just going to use the chrome sockets in the mechanics set you have. As you reach for them, there’s a nagging feeling that maybe there’s […]
Metabo HPT MultiVolt Triple Hammer Impact Driver Enters Second Generation Out of dozens of the cordless impact drivers we’ve tested, the Metabo HPT MultiVolt 36V Triple Hammer Impact Driver is one of the most unique with its 3-hammer design. There’s now a second-generation version, the WH36DCM, and we’re seeing how it compares to its predecessor. […]
As an Amazon Associate, we may earn income when you click on an Amazon link. Thanks for helping us do what we love.
See our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.
Pro Tool Reviews is a successful online publication that has been providing tool reviews and industry news since 2008. In today’s world of Internet news and online content, we found that more and more professionals researched a large majority of their major power tool purchases online. That piqued our interest.
There’s one key thing to note about Pro Tool Reviews: We’re all about the professional tool user and tradesman!
Copyright ©2008-2022 Pro Tool Reviews, LLC. All rights reserved.
Professional Tool Reviews for Pros